top of page

Solid Wood vs HDF: Choosing the Right Material for Wheels

Updated: Mar 16, 2023



As an experienced woodworker, I often receive inquiries about the different materials I use for my finished products. In this blog post, I would like to discuss the pros and cons of two materials, solid wood of various species and HDF (High-Density Fiberboard), and which one would be best for the wheels I offer.



 



Now, the wheels I offer come in a variety of thicknesses, ranging from 3/64 inch to 1.25 inch thick. HDF is ideal for thinner wheels needing a smooth surface, as it can be cut and shaped precisely without splitting or cracking. For thicker wheels, solid wood is an excellent choice because it provides better stability and durability.


Selecting the right wood species for craft/hobby wheels, decorative craft wheels, and furniture wheels that can withstand heavy loads is essential. While High-Density Fiberboard (HDF) is a reliable choice due to its uniformity and resistance to moisture damage, it has some disadvantages. On the other hand, solid wood species such as clear pine, red oak, poplar wood, African mahogany, walnut, and white oak offer various unique advantages, and some of them are eco-friendly.


Let's take a closer look at each material and its properties.


High-Density Fiberboard (HDF)


Eco-Friendly:

  • Made from recycled wood fibers, eco-friendly HDF can be a good option.

Technical Properties:

  • Uniformity multi-directional interlocking fibers ensure precise shapes and cuts.

  • Resistance to moisture damage.

  • HDF is at most 3/32 inches thick.

Advantages:

  • Excellent choice for craft/hobby wheels and decorative craft wheels due to its uniformity and resistance to moisture damage.

  • Perfect for Painting - smooth surface can resemble a metal finish after painting.

  • Very cost-effective - the least expensive option available

Disadvantages:

  • Being only 3/32 of an inch thick at most it lacks strength and durability for furniture wheels.

  • Not suitable for outdoor use.

  • Does not accept stains well

  • Though Super smooth on one side, the other side, though uniform does have texture and may not be suitable for all esthetic situations

 

Clear Pine


Eco-Friendly:

  • It is a fast-growing tree, and using it can help reduce the demand for other slower-growing species.

Technical Properties:

  • Softwood with a low density.

  • Offers a natural texture and grain pattern.

  • Can be stained or painted easily.

Advantages:

  • Provides natural texture and grain pattern, enhancing the overall aesthetic of craft/hobby and decorative craft wheels.

  • Low density makes it easy to work with and lightweight.

  • Can be painted or stained easily.

Disadvantages:

  • Lack of strength and durability for furniture wheels.

 

Red Oak


Eco-Friendly:

  • It is a domestic hardwood, and using it can help reduce the demand for imported hardwoods.

Technical Properties:

  • A hardwood with high density and strength.

  • Offers a natural texture and grain pattern.

  • Stains well and is easy to work with.

Advantages:

  • Provides natural texture and grain pattern, enhancing the overall aesthetic of craft/hobby and decorative craft wheels.

  • High density and strength make it suitable for furniture wheels that bear heavy loads.

  • Stains well and is easy to work with.

Disadvantages:

  • Less durable than other hardwoods like walnut and white oak.

  • Not very weather resistant as the wood fiber pattern allows for insects and moisture to penetrate if untreated.

 

Poplar Wood


Eco-Friendly:

  • Poplar is one of the fastest-growing hardwood trees in North America, making it a sustainable option.

Technical Properties:

  • A hardwood with low density and fine texture.

  • Accepts stains and paints well.

  • Resistant to warping and shrinking.

Advantages:

  • Lightweight and easy to work with, making it a good option for craft/hobby and decorative craft wheels.

  • Resistant to warping and shrinking, making it a suitable option for furniture wheels.

  • Accepts stains and paints well.

Disadvantages:

  • Less durable than other hardwoods like walnut and white oak.

 

African Mahogany


Eco-Friendly:

  • It is an FSC-certified and sustainable hardwood.

Technical Properties:

  • A hardwood with medium-density and fine texture.

  • Resistant to warping, shrinking, and swelling.

  • Accepts stains and finishes well.

Advantages:

  • Provides a natural texture and fine grain pattern, enhancing the overall aesthetic of craft/hobby and decorative craft wheels.

  • Medium density and resistance to warping, shrinking, and swelling make it suitable for furniture wheels.

  • Accepts stains and finishes well.

Disadvantages:


  • Less durable than other hardwoods like walnut and white oak.

 

Walnut


Eco-Friendly:

  • The demand for walnut has been increasing in recent years, which has led to better management of walnut forests to maintain their sustainability.

Technical Properties:

  • A dense and heavy hardwood with a beautiful natural grain pattern.

  • Resistant to decay and insect damage.

  • Accepts stains and finishes well.

Advantages:

  • Provides a beautiful natural grain pattern that enhances the aesthetic of craft/hobby and decorative craft wheels.

  • Its dense and heavy nature makes it suitable for furniture wheels that bear heavy loads.

  • Resistant to decay and insect damage.

Disadvantages:

  • More expensive than other hardwoods like clear pine and red oak.

 

White Oak


Eco-Friendly:

  • White oak is a domestically grown hardwood that can be sustainably harvested.

Technical Properties:

  • A strong and durable hardwood that is resistant to decay and moisture.

  • Accepts stains and finishes well.

  • Coarse texture and distinct grain pattern.

Advantages:

  • Its strong and durable nature makes it suitable for furniture wheels that bear heavy loads.

  • Resistant to decay and moisture, making it a reliable option for outdoor furniture wheels.

  • Coarse texture and distinct grain pattern provide a unique aesthetic to craft/hobby and decorative craft wheels.

Disadvantages:

  • More expensive than other hardwoods like clear pine and red oak.


In summary, both solid wood and HDF have their advantages and disadvantages, and choosing the right material will depend on the intended use of the product. HDF is perfect for craft/hobby wheels that require precision and uniformity. Solid wood is ideal for applications that require durability and a unique natural texture. I take pride in using eco-friendly and durable materials for my finished products, and regardless of the material used, my products are designed to be both beautiful and functional. Thank you for considering Wild Woodworker for your wooden wheels and if you have any further questions please do not hesitate to ask.








Comments


bottom of page